Capital Choize AZ - Student Loans

Retiring With $200,000 in Student Loans: The Math That Claims the Lion’s Share of Your Portfolio

Table of Contents

Could it make sense for you to retire with $200,000 remaining in student loans? If your portfolio is likely to fail at carrying that payment and the rest of your daily needs, I’d recommend you keep working.

This situation is walking into my office more often than you’d think. Somebody is 64, a couple years out, and there’s still a six figure student loan balance on the books. Usually Parent PLUS debt from putting the kids through school.

Run the .04 Math First

When Moneywise recently asked me whether you should retire at 64 with $200,000 in student loans, I walked through it the same way I do across the desk.

A $200,000 federal loan on the standard 10 year plan runs roughly $2,400 a month. If they’re planning on retiring by the 4% rule, effectively they’re going to need to take that monthly payment, multiply it by 12, then divide by .04, and that’s how much they need to earmark as the mechanism for being able to comfortably make those payments consistently during the retirement years. On $2,400 a month it works out to $720,000. For most people that’s a significant chunk if not the lion’s share of their retirement. 

Hypothetical illustration. Actual results will vary.

This math kinda works out in all aspects of debt when you’re trying to figure out a plan while sticking to the 4% rule. A $600 car payment needs $180,000 earmarked. A $1,500 mortgage needs $450,000.

Taking any extra distributions on that could be compounding towards the amount of taxes they’re going to end up paying, or amplify what they pay for other benefits such as Medicare, and can bring their Social Security up in taxation as well.

What Kind of Loan Is It

We need to have a conversation on whether it’s a federal student loan or a Parent PLUS student loan or a private loan, because they have different rules clearly. Different repayment options, different flexibility, different treatment down the road.

Juggling loans and retirement savings? Start with the free Ultimate Wealth Starter Toolkit. It includes a starter budget and a financial organizer so you can see where your money is going. Download the toolkit →

The Cash-Out Instinct

Typically it’s a person that’s looking to cash out their 401(k) early and pay a massive tax bill in order to pay off their house. Generally speaking they’re still working, a couple years away from retirement. They’re just like, well, let me cash out $200,000 now.

Then I run the math. Why would you want to pay 22% taxes when over time you might be able to reduce that tax bill by almost 50% by deferring, instead of taking withdrawals early? I show them what the math looks like and show them the probability of success by doing so.

The Moves That Have the Potential to Work

For the 64 year old trying to knock the balance out before retirement: check that your investments are actually providing you with the opportunity to grow your wealth and work for you. Get on a budget and stick to it. And as part of that budget, make cuts on things that are just unnecessary.

Then there’s downsizing.

It could be possible to sell a $650,000 residence and move into a $400,000 residence and after fees and expenses walk out with $200,000 and a more manageable house that costs less in electricity and upkeep. Maybe some of that pays off the mortgage from the old place and you’re walking into a mortgage free home with $100,000 left. Now the math is a little easier over the long run. With less debt that needs to be repaid, you can keep the same payment you were going to go into it with anyways and get it knocked out in far less time. Assuming they qualify to avoid capital gains taxes on their primary residence, downsizing can be the shovel that empowers them to retire with less when they want to.

There’s a lot of benefits with downsizing and one of the biggest ones is the fact that you don’t have to clean up nearly as much home. I remind clients, you’re heading into retirement, you’re supposed to be enjoying your time, not spending the whole time cleaning up the house that you live in now.

Often the kids get kind of weird about it because it’s the house they grew up in. So I give the parents the added conversation. Your kids aren’t paying for your retirement and you don’t want them to, so we’re doing what’s in our best interest. Doing this is going to give us a stronger relationship and give us more time to help you guys on the other end, with both time and money.

Consistent Income Is the Whole Plan

When a 64 year old with a big loan balance opens up their statements for me, the thing that’s broken is consistent, reliable retirement income. Consistent income is what allows the plan to stay on track. When we look at a remaining loan balance and there’s no spot where the income can consistently service it, they can’t get on a budget. And if they can’t get on a budget, they can’t comfortably feel they’re hitting their goals.

The Takeaway

Take your monthly student loan payment, multiply it by 12, then divide by .04. That’s the portion of your portfolio needed to carry that student loan payment. If what remains from your portfolio can’t carry your other monthly needs, I’d recommend you keep working, get tighter on your budget, and take a good hard look at what you’re spending.

Ready to talk it through? Book a complimentary 30-minute call. There’s nothing to bring and no charge for the appointment.

Chris Walsh is a Senior Advisor and Regional Director at Capital Choice Arizona in Phoenix, AZ.

Hypothetical illustrations throughout; actual results will vary. Case studies are composites based on actual client experiences; names and details changed; results not typical. Comparisons are for educational purposes only and do not represent a recommendation. Tax implications vary by individual situation; consult a tax professional.

Please Note: This article is for informational purposes only, and should not be construed as legal, tax or financial advice. Capital Choice Arizona provides investment advisory services through CoreCap Advisors, LLC. Capital Choice Arizona and CoreCap Advisors, LLC are separate and unaffiliated entities.

Facebook
X
Email
LinkedIn
Reddit